Adrian Hedden
Artesia Daily Press
achedden@elritomedia.com
Republicans in Bernalillo and Sandoval counties are demanding that Otero County Commissioner Amy Barela vacate her position as state GOP chair, claiming she is violating a party rule they say prohibits a state party officer from running for public office against another Republican.
Barela is currently an Otero County Commissioner and running for reelection. She is refusing to resign as GOP Party chair and insists the rule does not apply to her candidacy in the June 2 primary where she is seeking her party’s nomination to run for a second term as District 2 county commissioner in the November general election.
The rule, Barela says, is intended to prevent a party official from challenging a fellow Republican and because she filed for the primary before her opponent did, she is not challenging him.
And she contends a recent legal opinion backs up her assertions. The Republican Party of New Mexico shared a “Parliamentarian Review” it commissioned in support of Barela on March 27 via its Facebook page, which is also used to promote Republican candidates across the state.
The review, conducted by Kay Allison Crews, a professional registered parliamentarian based in Dallas argued the rule only applies when a party officer files to run for an elected position after their opponent in the Republican primary.
“She would have no notice that she was required to vacate her party office, because the triggering condition — the existence of a competing Republican filing — had not yet occurred,” Crews wrote.
“The way the rule is written, I declared first. I am not opposing anybody. I am being opposed,” Barela said.
Barela’s opponent is Jonathan Emery, who filed for the June 2 primary the same day as Barela, March 10, but two minutes later. Barela filed at 9:06 a.m. and Emery filed at 9:08 a.m.
Emery announced his candidacy in January along with plans to retire this year as a sergeant with the Otero County Sheriff’s Office.
Otero County Commissioners receive a $30,000 annual salary along with health and life insurance benefits. State party chair is an unpaid position.
As chair, Barela is tasked with leading statewide funding efforts for political campaigns by Republican candidates. She also holds speaking events and works to rally support among voters.
The rule at issue, which is included in the New Mexico GOP’s bylaws, states:
“In the event the state chairman or any other state officer of the Republican State Central Committee files as a candidate for public office and there is another Republican who has filed for the same office, the state officer shall immediately vacate the party office.”
Sandoval County Republican Chair Beth Dowling says Barela is deliberately misinterpreting the rule, which Dowling maintains is intended to prevent a conflict of interest when a party officer runs against a fellow Republican in a primary election, regardless of who filed first.
“The rule is straightforward. It has nothing to do with an interpretation of when somebody files or if an individual is an incumbent,” Dowling said. “She has essentially vacated the position as state chair. That’s the situation at hand.”
“It’s all about following the rules,” Dowling said.
Rural-urban divide
The argument now shapes up as an urban-rural wrangle, Barela believes, with big-city Republicans in the northern part of the state determined to oust the duly elected chairperson from Otero County.
Barela was elected to a two-year term as chair by the GOP’s State Central Committee in December 2024, succeeding longtime Congressman Steve Pearce of Hobbs. She previously served as the party’s chairperson for the 2nd Congressional District, covering most of the rural southern portion of the state.
Barela said her position at the head of the statewide GOP gives representation to the rural areas of southern New Mexico, a deep-red region she said is underrepresented both via a strong Democratic Party majority in the Legislature and within the Republican Party itself.
“I’m not sure there is a Republican in Bernalillo County. They don’t have the same value system as in southern New Mexico. That’s very apparent.” Barela said. “They dictate everything.”
New Mexico Sen. Jim Townsend (R-34) of Artesia supported Barela’s rule interpretation and her theory that calls for her resignation are an attempt to remove her as chair and replace her with someone more amenable to northern New Mexico’s views.
“That rural-urban divide is everywhere in New Mexico,” Townsend said. “Just because you’re a big county doesn’t mean you’re the best county, or the smartest county. What they’re doing is not healthy.”
Barela’s opponent said when he announced his candidacy that the incumbent commissioner should step down as party chair “if the rules dictate that she does so” but in an emailed statement to the Alamogordo News said he did not enter the primary to force Barela out of her party job.
“I want to make it very clear I was not planted by any party to run against Amy,” Emery said. “In fact, my run for commissioner has nothing to do with Amy. I wish her the best of luck.”
Emery said his eligibility for retirement from the sheriff’s office prompted his decision to enter the commission race this year.
A group of anti-Barela Republicans weighed in with an 11-page memo sent to members of the party’s State Central Committee in early March arguing that Barela the primary candidate cannot also be Barela the chairperson and that she forfeited the chairmanship the moment she filed to run in the primary.
The State Central Committee is the governing body of the New Mexico GOP, tasked with approving rules and policies as to how the party operates internally.
Party rules state that to remove Barela without her resignation, a party member needs a 2/3 majority quorum representing at least 13 counties to hold a meeting at which the post could officially be declared vacant. Bernalillo and Sandoval counties admitted they have only a 56% majority in favor of Barela’s removal, meaning such a meeting has yet to be called.
Still, the Bernalillo and Sandoval county organizations say Barela is in violation of the rules by being both a party officer and contested primary candidate, and that they intend to fill the seat with someone less conflicted.
At this point Barela disagrees and continues as an Otero County Commissioner up for reelection and the current GOP chair.
But regardless of this outcome of the conflict, the continued internal strife within the party is harming its national reputation, said 1st Vice Chair of the Bernalillo County GOP Mark Murton.
“We believe leadership is hard,” he said. “It’s not like you can order people around. You have to build consensus and inspire. That’s what we need.”
Managing Editor Adrian Hedden can be reached at 575-628-5516, or @AdrianHedden on the social media platform X.




















