Dear Editor,
I am writing to share some insight into a cultural holiday that has stirred debate — changing the celebration of Columbus Day (CD) to Indigenous Peoples Day (IPD). My hope is to invite understanding rather than division about why someone might wish to “rewrite history.”
I offer this from my perspective as an independent thinker. Although I may attend both Democratic and Republican events, I’ve been a registered Independent since 2008, when I began questioning the status quo. That questioning extends beyond politics to my values and traditions. I ask myself whether I should continue celebrating things simply because they were passed down—or choose to celebrate what truly aligns with my values.
Growing up, I was taught to celebrate CD and was told in school that Christopher Columbus “discovered” America. It wasn’t until later that I learned Columbus never reached North America — he landed in the Bahamas while searching for India. I also learned that Italian Americans, who faced discrimination at the time, began celebrating Columbus as a symbol of ethnic pride. Eventually, in 1937, CD became a federal holiday.
Years later, while organizing a community calendar, I discovered IPD through a “Peace Calendar” that highlighted global events of peace and justice — Earth Day, International Women’s Day, and others. This opened my eyes to the stories of people whose histories were ignored or erased. I began to recognize Indigenous Peoples Day as a meaningful alternative that honors resilience, culture, and truth.
As I learned more about colonization, of which Columbus was a part, I couldn’t ignore the suffering it caused — the near-eradication of entire nations and cultures of Indigenous peoples. While I can celebrate my relationship with my country, celebrating the harm done by colonization and the leaders who initiated it is not in line with my values.
While I don’t believe today’s generation is responsible for the actions of the past, I do believe we carry a responsibility to learn from it. Acknowledging this history allows for healing, redemption, and a measure of balance. It is a way to honor those who endured profound loss, including our Mescalero neighbors, and to say, “We see you.”
I am also drawn to Native philosophies that honor the inter-connectedness of life — the land, water, and all living beings. This worldview reminds us of our shared responsibility to care for each other and the Earth. This understanding strengthens my appreciation for acknowledging IPD.
Whether one chooses to celebrate Columbus Day or Indigenous Peoples Day, my hope is that we all take time to reflect on what and why we celebrate. As New Mexicans, may we honor our pledge that acknowledges our diverse cultures and views. May we listen to one another with open hearts and respect perspectives different from our own.
Celebrating Indigenous Peoples Day is, to me, a celebration of truth, peace, and healing.
Sincerely,
Andrea Fernandez

